Dans le cadre d'un MAPA, peut-on retenir comme critère de jugement des offres un critère de recevabilité des candidatures ?

In the context of a MAPA, can we accept as criteria for judging offers a criterion for the admissibility of applications?

by gmorales on August 2nd, 2011 | Category: Pre-contractual & Contractual referral
Dans le cadre d'un MAPA, peut-on retenir comme critère de jugement des offres un critère de recevabilité des candidatures ? Dans le cadre d'un MAPA, peut-on retenir comme critère de jugement des offres un critère de recevabilité des candidatures ?

CE 2 August 2011, Sté Regional Natural Park of Grands Causses, req.n ° 348254

Rules for formalized procedures

In a formalized procedure, the Council of State forbids the use as a criterion for judging offers a criterion of receivability of applications such as the turnover where professional references (EC 29 December 2006, SNC Bertele, n ° 273783) .

Possible flexibilities for adapted procedures

In an adapted procedure, the Council of State authorizes as criterion of judgment of the offers a criterion of admissibility of the candidatures as for example the professional references to a double condition:

Condition n ° 1: The consideration of this criterion must be justified by the purpose of the contract.

In this case, the Council of State considers that a market which aims at the realization of seventy energy pre-diagnoses on public buildings, schools, town halls, communal dwellings, village halls as well as on educational establishments. health centers, campsites, rural lodges, holiday centers and hotels, which provides for the completion of an energy assessment for each building as well as an evaluation of energy saving deposits and a direction towards interventions that are simple to implement. or in-depth studies present a particular technicality that objectively justifies the use of the criterion of professional references.

Condition n ° 2: The consideration of this criterion must not have any discriminatory effect.